A funny thing’s happened on the way to a possible Asian soybean rust epidemic in the U.S. Researchers at both chemical companies and universities are discovering more benefits of fungicide use on both soybeans and corn.
“Danger of rust has brought the awareness of fungicides to the fore,” says Randy Myers, fungicide product manager with Bayer. “There’s been a lot of testing of them on soybeans to see what they do in the absence of rust — then that’s moved on to corn.”
Don’t Rest On Rust
While the past two seasons have been relatively dry — literally and figuratively — for rust in the Midwest, companies and researchers CropLife® talked with continue to sound the alarm. “If the conditions are right, it’s the most aggressive disease I’ve experienced in my agricultural career over 30 years,” says Mats Edh, vice president, marketing with Cheminova.
Later in the 2006 season, the disease was found in Mexico and Texas, and if discoveries of the spore are made earlier this year, there’s greater danger for Midwest soybeans. Myers explains that prevailing wind directions in the U.S. more easily carry inoculum from those areas than from the Southeast — from where the spores need to play hopscotch to travel north. “A lot of weather patterns from the Southwest can move it right up the Mississippi River and into the major soybean growing areas,” he explains.
A number of company reps believe our industry still doesn’t have a really good handle on what the disease will do under U.S. environmental conditions — the climate in Brazil where rust first hit hard is just too different to make too many projections for this continent.
“Soybean rust isn’t hard to fight, there are a lot of tools out there shown to be effective,” says Bayer‘s Myers, whose company offers Folicur (tebuconazole), a top seller in Brazil. “But timing is critical. Each product needs to be applied within its proper application window, and some products have a narrower window than others. Retailers and growers need to understand the strengths and weaknesses of each of their chemical options to get the best disease activity.”
At the National Soybean Rust Symposium, the triazole class was touted as the best for soybean rust control, Nielson reports. “Last year, even at the university level, it was not clear what to use. This year, they’ve got more exposure with rust in the U.S.” He notes that there are currently seven or eight triazoles “out there,” all waiting for Section 3 clearance, including Valent’s Domark (tetraconazole).
Myers notes that Southwest growers have become accustomed to using fungicides on soybeans for the past five to seven years because they’ve been going after other diseases such as Cercospora and aerial blight. “That mentality will serve as a template for growers farther north that really haven’t had a need for applying fungicides.”
Retailers will play a key role in helping farmers determine whether to spray for rust, says Nielson. He says his company receives grower e-mails forwarded from USDA’s rust Web site. “We’ll then forward them to our sales force and they send them on to the retailers. We really rely on the retailers to be the vocal point. We focus on educating them, to make sure they’re more aware of rust and its movement.”
Valent offers Domark 230ME, a micro-emulsion formulation specifically designed for soybeans that’s awaiting Section 3 approval. The company says the formulation pours very nicely, has no odor — and helps spread across the plant, then be actively absorbed by the leaf.
Corn Gets A Dose
While rust often grabs the spotlight, experts agreed that gray leaf spot infestations were on the rise last year in corn, due in part to the move to reduced tillage — which provides a cozy place for inoculum numbers to grow. “With the potential for increased acres and more corn on corn rotations, the potential for gray leaf spot could increase in ’07 due to overwintering of the inoculum on residue,” says Syngenta’s Eichorn. He reports growers using Quilt saw an average increase of 15.5 bushels/acre more than an untreated check.
Bayer’s Myers notes that gray leaf spot is a real problem for growers in the Plains states where irrigation keeps moisture levels high. “The activity of Stratego, on the disease is excellent, so growers saw a very nice yield bump,” says Myers. The product, a triazole/strobilurin combination, has been a top performer in rice — even credited with improving milling quality as well as yield — but it wasn’t until last season that the product impacted corn.
The tricky part for fungicide application on corn is how. Timing to apply is around tassel/silk initiation when plants are huge. “A lot more airplanes will be spraying fungicides on corn than what we’ve had historically,” says Myers.
Perhaps even more dicey: convincing Midwest growers they even need a late-season fungicide, especially considering there hasn’t been a massive disease infestation since Southern corn leaf blight back in the ’70s. “It’s going to take a shift in their paradigm to suddenly think there are inputs and concerns later in the season. These are new tools that can help increase yields,” says Myers, whose family has farmed for generations without late-season applications. Typically growers have relied on breeding programs to build resistance into hybrids so that diseases have only caused a small yield drag. Newer, much more effective classes of chemistries in recent years are debunking old ideas that fungicides can’t help.
Troy Bettner, senior product/marketing manager for fungicides with Makhteshim Agan of North America, says that 18 trials with Bumper (propiconazole) logged an average yield increase of 10 bushels/acre of corn. The fungicide — as well as the company’s Orius formulations (tebuconazole) — have Section 18 labels.
BASF reports 12 to 15 bushel/acre yield increases with Headline (pyraclostrobin) applications. Why the gain? “Besides gray leaf spot, we know there are diseases out there, but they’re not always evident to growers,” says Gary Fellows, product manager with BASF.
Plant Health Means Higher Yields
But the enhanced productivity of strobilurin-treated crops can no longer just be attributed to good disease control. In both soybeans and corn, better plant performance because of fungicide applications became more evident in 2006. Fellows says Headline makes plants healthier, more efficient in plant growth, and more resistant to stress. “We’ve had reports out of Texas and Mississippi, where there was a lot of drought stress. Once they did get a rain, Headline-treated corn came out of the drought very rapidly with less damage. Hail damaged fields also came out quicker and out-yielded untreated crops,” he says. Growers said combining was easier and more efficient because plants weren’t lodged — stalks were stronger.
“In soybeans we’re seeing a very similar thing,” he adds. Indeed, Kip Cullers, the Missouri grower who logged the 2006 World Record soybean yield at 139 bushels/acre, credits a part of success to Headline. (Fellows also points out that Headline is providing “one of the highest levels of rust control” as well as controlling other yield-robbing soybean diseases such as frogeye and septoria.)
Our experts encouraged dealers to use the Web to find other information showing yield advantages from fungicide applications under various conditions. Says Myers: “Retailers need to be looking for information germane to their geography so they can communicate to the growers that there’s a real benefit out there. The biggest challenge I think retailers will be facing is convincing growers there’s something else that can bump up those yields.
“It’s a change in the way growers approach things. We’ll see this coming season just how widely accepted it becomes.”