The Effectiveness Of Nutrient Management Plans

UPDATED: January 28, 2013

Nutrient management plans (NMPs) are implemented to supply plants with ideal amounts of nutrients, minimize runoff pollutants, and maintain or improve the soil condition. As we continue to understand the effects farming practices have on the environment, NMPs present farmers with a set of conservation practices designed to reduce harmful pollutants while obtaining optimal crop yields.

Many U.S. Animal Feeding Operations (AFOs) produce excess N and P compared with the nutrient requirements of their cropland, and more regulations are being implemented to help reduce the pollution. In 1998, in response to President Clinton’s Clean Water Action Plan, the USDA and USEPA developed a Unified National Strategy to minimize the effects of AFOs on water quality and public health.

Today, each state has a different set of guidelines for NMPs, most of which involve farmers developing field-by-field records of nutrient applications. Currently, only Delaware and Maryland have nutrient management laws requiring all farmers to implement NMPs.

A study published in the March–April 2012 Agronomy Journal evaluates how effectively four dairy farms implemented their own NMPs from 1999 to 2005. The researchers, from the University of Connecticut and the USDA, compared the farmers’ reported practices with the recommended manure and fertilizer management plans and evaluated whether manure and fertilizer management had significant effects on the nutrient status of soil and corn tissue tests.

The majority of the cropland of the four farms selected for this study was used for corn silage, with substantial acreage also used for grass hay. The farmers’ priority for management and nutrient tests was corn, so only corn fields were used in this study. Each of the soils at the four farms had sandy loam to loam texture, a slope of 0% to 8%, organic matter content of 3 to 6%, and were moderately well to well-drained.

The NMPs of each farm consisted of two parts: a baseline year and the implementation years. In the baseline year, the research team collected information about each farm’s nutrient management. The factors considered included the number of livestock, cropland acreage, nutrient status of the cropland, manure production, manure management, and fertilizer management.

The farmers kept field-by-field records about manure and fertilizer applications but made no changes to the management of their nutrients. The information collected in the baseline year was used to develop field-by-field recommendations for manure and fertilizer management to be applied in the subsequent implementation years. The recommendations were based primarily on soil tests.

The rate of manure recommended was based on the amount of P needed by the crop, which researchers estimated from soil test results. If the farm had excess manure after fulfilling the crop’s P needs, recommendations were made to apply manure at a rate equal to the amount of P expected to be removed by the crop. If the farm still had manure leftover, it was to be applied to fields to meet the N requirement for the crop to fields that had a low potential to export P to water bodies. Chemical fertilizer recommendations were made after all manure was allocated.

Soil samples were routinely collected by farmers or crop advisers and analyzed at the University of Connecticut Soil Testing Laboratory. Samples were taken from the surface 30-cm layer from most of the fields in late spring when the corn was 15 to 30 cm tall. The samples underwent pre-sidedress nitrogen tests (PSNTs), which indicate how much nitrogen is available in the soil.

Cornstalk samples were also collected for corn stalk nitrate tests (CSNTs), which provide a retrospective assessment of a season’s nitrogen management. Farmers collected 15 cornstalk samples from each field during the period ranging from one week prior to harvest through one day after harvest.

During the implementation years, farmers were provided the results of the PSNT test and the recommended N sidedress. However, the percentage of times the farmers that actually applied the recommended N rate when the sidedress N recommendation was greater than zero was low, ranging from 6% to 24%.

The percentage of times the farmers applied the recommended N rate ranged from 79% to 90% when the recommended rate was zero. This data implies that farmers were not likely to follow recommendations derived from PSNT tests when the recommendation was to apply N. This behavior is supported by scientific reports showing that PSNT tests are most reliable when the N recommendation is zero.

The farmers applied fertilizer P at the recommended rate in the NMPs in the majority of the fields. In most years, more than 50% of the fields received a recommendation of zero fertilizer P, and farmers tended to follow that recommendation. Across the four farms, the overapplication of P occurred in less than 3% of the field-by-year combinations. This data shows that farmers were willing to adopt P fertilizer recommendations provided in their NMPs.

Only a small percentage of the fields, ranging from 3% to 37%, received the recommended amount of manure N and P. Variability in the amount of residual N available from previous manure applications caused great variance in the PSNT and CSNT tests, indicating that several years of data are needed before these tests can be used to accurately evaluate the performance of a NMP.

The four farmers in this study seemed confident that fertilizer recommendations were appropriate when based on soil tests, especially recommendations for fertilizer P. However, there was no significant change in soil test P values, probably due to the large spatial variation of P in the fields.

The results from this study showed no decreasing trend in the concentrations of nitrate in the PSNT and CSNT tests. The large variation in the amounts of manure and fertilizer applied by the farmers may be responsible for this lack of improvement.

Only a small percentage of fields received the recommended amount of manure application, and no significant decrease in the amount of manure over application compared with the recommended amount was found in this study.

Documenting improvements in N and P management after the implementation of an NMP proved to be a difficult task for the researchers of this study, due to both biological and management factors, such as non-uniform manure spreading and annual variations in weather, especially rainfall.  

Overall, the researchers say that manure and fertilizer management on dairy farms could be improved by using a longer timeframe than the three- to five-year plans typically used by NMPs. Management plans implemented using a process of adaptive management for N, which provides more detailed, continuous evaluations about the N status of corn fields, have also been shown to improve N management.

Leave a Reply

Crop Inputs Stories

Syngenta Seedcare Institute
Seed/BiotechSyngenta Opens New North America Seedcare Institute In Stanton, MN
September 23, 2016
Syngenta unveiled its new Seedcare Institute in Stanton, MN, during a recent grand opening celebration. More than 150 industry leaders, Read More
Crop InputsJim Loar Promoted To President And CEO Of Cool Planet
September 22, 2016
In a move that reflects and reinforces the company’s commitment to the agricultural market, the Cool Planet board of directors Read More
Crop InputsMonsanto, Bayer Officials Defend Proposed $66 Billion Merger
September 21, 2016
Top officials for Monsanto and Bayer defended their proposed $66 billion merger before skeptical senators on Tuesday, insisting that the Read More
Corn
Crop InputsEPA Settles With Syngenta For Alleged Multi-Regional Pesticide Violations
September 19, 2016
The U.S. EPA has announced a multi-region settlement with Syngenta Crop Protection, LLC (Syngenta) in Greensboro, NC, for alleged violations of Read More
Trending Articles
Corn Field
Eric SfiligojFacing Ag Industry Challenges
September 26, 2016
At the 2016 annual Mid America CropLife Association (MACA) meeting in September, a pair of crop protection company representatives discussed Read More
Bayer Monsanto
Crop InputsBayer-Monsanto Mega-Merger: 6 Things You Need To Know
September 14, 2016
Mega mergers have become almost routine in the agricultural industry. Right on the heels of Monday’s news that fertilizer giants Potash Read More
Potash Corp Agrium
Crop InputsAgrium, Potash Corp To Merge To Create $36 Billion Company
September 12, 2016
Canada’s Agrium Inc. and Potash Corp of Saskatchewan Inc. have agreed to combine in a deal that would create a Read More
Osage Co-op Elevator Osage, IA Finished Building
OpinionAre We Crazy?
September 8, 2016
At some point in the first few months of my employment here at CropLife® magazine, I started getting curious about Read More
ManagementMAGIE 2016 Highlights and Deere Anti-Trust
September 1, 2016
CropLife Editor Eric Sfiligoj discusses the recent Midwest AG Industries Exposition and the Department of Justice’s objection to John Deere Read More
ASMARK 2016 Retailers Live! Tour - CPS
CropLife 100CPS Acquires Texas Retail Operation
August 23, 2016
Crop Production Services (CPS) has acquired the assets of Larry’s Chemical and Spray, Inc., for an undisclosed amount in an Read More
Latest News
Growmark FS Outlet
Industry NewsGROWMARK To Purchase Suncor’s Share Of UPI
September 26, 2016
GROWMARK and Suncor have reached an agreement in which GROWMARK will purchase Suncor’s 50% interest in UPI, Inc. in Ontario, Read More
Corn Field
Eric SfiligojFacing Ag Industry Challenges
September 26, 2016
At the 2016 annual Mid America CropLife Association (MACA) meeting in September, a pair of crop protection company representatives discussed Read More
Syngenta Seedcare Institute
Seed/BiotechSyngenta Opens New North America Seedcare Institute In …
September 23, 2016
Syngenta unveiled its new Seedcare Institute in Stanton, MN, during a recent grand opening celebration. More than 150 industry leaders, Read More
StewardshipMonsanto Invests $1.6 Million In System To Quantify Gre…
September 23, 2016
The USDA – Natural Resources Conservation Service (USDA-NRCS) recently awarded the National Corn Growers Association (NCGA) and its Soil Health Read More
Pipe rack
LegislationCourt Sides With Ag Retailers On PSM
September 23, 2016
The D.C. Court of Appeals has ruled the Occupational Safety and Health Administration violated the Occupational Safety and Health Act when Read More
ManagementPacific Coast Fertilizer Announces Interest In Longview…
September 22, 2016
Pacific Coast Fertilizer LP (PCF) announced at the Cowlitz Economic Development Council board of directors meeting its interest in developing Read More
Young corn plants in soil
UncategorizedCool Planet Raises Additional $9 Million To Commerciali…
September 22, 2016
Cool Planet has announced the first close of a new financing round to commercialize the company’s Cool Terra Engineered Biocarbon Read More
Crop InputsJim Loar Promoted To President And CEO Of Cool Planet
September 22, 2016
In a move that reflects and reinforces the company’s commitment to the agricultural market, the Cool Planet board of directors Read More
BlendersNorth Dakota Coop Debuts Dry Fertilizer Plant
September 22, 2016
North Central Grain Cooperative has begun operations at a new dry fertilizer plant at its Rolla, ND, site. It is Read More
Crop InputsMonsanto, Bayer Officials Defend Proposed $66 Billion M…
September 21, 2016
Top officials for Monsanto and Bayer defended their proposed $66 billion merger before skeptical senators on Tuesday, insisting that the Read More
ManagementUpcoming Shows & Recent Events
September 19, 2016
Editors Paul Schrimpf and Eric Sfiligoj talk about upcoming trade shows and events and review the Mid America CropLife Association Read More
Industry NewsVerdesian Life Sciences Appoints New CEO
September 19, 2016
Verdesian Life Sciences, a plant health and nutrition company, today announced that its board of directors has named Kenneth M. Avery Read More
Corn
Crop InputsEPA Settles With Syngenta For Alleged Multi-Regional Pe…
September 19, 2016
The U.S. EPA has announced a multi-region settlement with Syngenta Crop Protection, LLC (Syngenta) in Greensboro, NC, for alleged violations of Read More
ManagementMerger Mania
September 16, 2016
Editors Paul Schrimpf and Eric Sfiligoj discuss this week’s mega-ag mergers of Bayer and Monsanto and Potash and Agrium. Read More
Monsanto sign
Crop InputsMonsanto Ends Up Being A Bargain For Bayer
September 16, 2016
History will say Bayer got a bargain in its $66 billion purchase of Monsanto, writes David Nicklaus, St. Louis Post-Dispatch. The Read More
Greg Musson, Gar Tootelian
CropLife 100California Ag Retailer Steps Up To Feed Families Affect…
September 16, 2016
GAR Tootelian, Inc. (GAR) in Reedley, CA, is challenging the Central Valley to help raise enough money and provide 525,000 meals Read More
Crop InputsBayer, Monsanto CEOs Discuss Merger
September 15, 2016
Werner Baumann, Bayer CEO, and Hugh Grant, Monsanto CEO, discuss why they decided to merge their companies. Read More
Corn close up
Crop InputsNY Times: Bayer-Monsanto a Bad Deal for Farmers
September 15, 2016
Via NY Times: Don Halcomb, a 63-year-old farmer in Adairville, KY, is expecting his profit to vanish this year, largely Read More