The Risky Business Of Fertilizer

Wabash River
With record plantings, 2008 was expected to be a boom time for fertilizer dealers. But not all realized the promise of increased sales — in fact, some retailers reported a dip in product movement. Why the drop in spite of healthy crop prices and deeper grower pocketbooks? Uncharacteristic rain and cold this spring were culprits, as was the catastrophic flooding experienced in parts of the Midwest.

“Flooding along the Wabash River in Indiana took many acres out of production or converted corn acres to soybeans,” says Jim Swinney, general manager, Posey County Co-op, Mt. Vernon, IN.

Dave Coppess, executive vice president at Heartland Co-Op, West Des Moines, IA, reports wet weather as well, with sizeable acreage never drying out enough for planting or forced into replanting because of wet spots. His company’s fertilizer sales were also lower because customers were doing variable-rate application, putting down less product.

Then, too, growers were admittedly balking at the higher prices, which were fueled in part by stronger-than-ever global competition for fertilizer. “Some of the farmers are talking of cutting back on pounds per acre due to high prices,” says Swinney, “but we’ve heard more talk than action due to the high commodity prices. If we see a continued softening of grain prices, we will see a cut back of application.”

Brent Sutton, president of Growers Fertilizer Co-op, Lake Alfred, FL, says his volumes were indeed down because of price points. In his specialty crop market (citrus, vegetables, ranches, turfgrass, and homeowners), fertilizer costs in some cases tripled and customers are now worried. “I really believe that we’re really going to start seeing a lot of fertilizer applications get cut back next year,” he says. Here too, commodity prices are a key factor — in this case for fruits and vegetables facing stiff foreign competition.

But some dealers did enjoy increased income. “Margins were excellent as the appreciation on purchases were outstanding. We couldn’t make a wrong buying decision as prices continued to increase through the season,” says Larry Stivers, sales at marketing director with Miles Farm Supply, Owensboro, KY. “It was our best year ever by two-and-half times.”

“Prices and pricing were crazy this year,” agrees Case DeYoung, branch manager at Wil­bur-Ellis, Sparta, MI. “Products appreciated nearly daily. We would fret about the timing of a purchase and by the time we got the product in and sold, in some cases it doubled in value.” In fact, DeYoung says fertilizer sales at his location were greater than 25% higher by volume than last year.

Even though Miles Farm Supply had a great season for profits, actual volume was down some 19%, as growers did a “pushback” when prices when up, says Stivers. “For 2009, we anticipate more of the same pushback from farmers, especially on phosphate rates.”

Taking Care Of Customers

Heartland‘s Coppess tries to put the fertilizer picture into perspective for customers. He’s done some number crunching, gathering data on crop input costs from Iowa State University as well as plugging in his own retail figures. In 2002, growers spent about 32% of their revenues on seed, fertilizer, and ag chemicals. Then, from 2003-08, the figure crept up to 40%. For 2009, he projects an average input cost of $405 per acre — then with a traditional yield at $6 a bushel for corn, growers would be spending 39%. “It’s relative. When the farmer looks at his input costs as a percentage of his total revenues, it’s not too disruptive, really,” says Coppess. “It’s what he’s used to paying.”

To save customers money, Heartland Co-op is encouraging variable-rate application. The company does grid sampling, dividing fields into three types of management zones. Applications are tailored to match the needs of those zones.

“We’re constantly trying to come up with the least-cost options for our customers,” says Grower Fertilizer Co-op’s Sutton. Half of his sales staff is certified crop advisors with the expertise to make such recommendations. They’re also able to refer growers to equipment like the Seeing Eye for citrus groves — “it will not fertilize unless the tree is right next to the spreader,” he explains.

Advice to growers can come in other forms. Wilbur-Ellis’ DeYoung noted that this year saw a large increase in sales of slow release liquid nitrogen products over last year. He credits some of the new corn hybrids that need larger doses of nitrogen later in the season. DeYoung sees opportunity here for dealers who can identify nutrient demand curves for specific crops and then time the use and application of nutrients. “The folks that can do this will return more to a customer for each dollar he spends on inputs,” says DeYoung. “This will make a dealer a very valuable business partner.”

Financial Incentives

Many retailers are offering farm financing, contracting programs, and prepay programs for fertilizer this fall, so customers anticipating higher spring prices can reserve product. “We’re running prepaid price programs to give them the benefit of early prices and bring us in some cash flow,” says Posey County Co-op’s Swinney.

Dealers are also investigating products that just plain make farmers’ applications go farther. One such product has been the Agrotain, which reduces nitrogen losses and extends plant-available nitrogen. It’s the world’s first and only commercially available urea or urea-ammonium nitrate (UAN) additive that stops nitrogen volatilization for up to 14 days, explains Mike Stegmann, president of wholesale distributor Lange-Stegmann, St. Louis, MO.

More growers have been turning to the Agrotain in the last few years; in fact, “sales nationally have shot through the roof.” Miles Farm Supply’s Stivers reports that sales of the product at his dealership increased 25% this past season.

Growers Fertilizer Co-op’s Sutton has been checking out an item called MPPA Duo for citrus and vegetables from a French company, Timac. The University of Florida Experiment station is testing the additive, which has been reported to cut fertilizer use by 25%, he says.

Stegmann notes that the industry is starting to see less reputable products coming on the market, as companies try to take advantage of growers concerns about high fertilizer prices. He would encourage dealers and growers to ensure any additives they try are researched thoroughly — and well respected by the research community.
Solutions for growers will revolve around nutrient use efficiency, however that may be achieved, says Stegmann, and will be driven not only by high fertilizer prices but environmental concerns.

Business Strategies

Retailers have been trying to take care of themselves as well as their customers. A major strategy has been to stock up on as much fertilizer as possible. Posey County Co-op put up a 5,000-ton storage building some five years ago, and “it’s helped us dramatically, to be able to buy ahead,” says Swinney. “Now we wish we had built it twice as big.” In fact, the company is looking at further expansion projects.

The hunt for potash is particularly challenging. “Even though we can store two-thirds of a season’s requirements, we’re having to allocate more time than ever on this search process,” he says. “There are fewer suppliers willing to sell, pricing is no longer negotiable, decisions must be made immediately, and quantities are limited — rather than buying barges, which is our norm, we’re now buying 500- and 1,000-ton lots.”

Companies that blend their own fertilizer should look for ways to reduce shrink, notes Sutton.

And as mentioned earlier, dealers have been taking advantage of appreciating product values, charging fair-market prices for nutrient inputs.

“We’re going to have to be willing to change,” says Swinney. “We need flexibility in buying ahead, finding the cash to buy ahead, selling off some of our risk through prepaids with customers, and controlling our risks in receivables.”

What’s Ahead

Opinions are mixed as to what the future holds for the fertilizer market.

Availability. While nitrogen and phosphate are still accessible, Stegmann notes the supply/demand balance for potash is extremely tight — and has the potential to go higher. “If there was any nutrient I was comfortable to buy today if I wasn’t going to use or sell till next spring, it would probably be potash,” he says.

Cash flow/capital requirements. Cash flow will continue to be a challenge at multiple levels of the market chain. And Stegmann points out “so much more money” is needed for dealers to operate at the same level they’ve done in the past because products cost two, three, and even four times as much.

Companies that also do business in grain will especially feel the pinch. “If you’re doing any forward buying of grain from customers, you need to get some pretty significant cash flow to buy $6 corn and $14 beans and maintain a futures position with the carries in the fertilizer market and the margin call that goes along with this volatility,” says Heartland’s Coppess.

Prices and risks. Stegmann believes costs will remain at current levels for at least another season and would link high fertilizer prices to current high grain/food demand and costs.

“I think prices are going to continue to go up at a pretty rapid pace, based on the projections I’m looking at,” says Coppess. “We could see another 20%.”

Stegmann would caution that as fast as the price of fertilizer has gone up, it can come down equally as fast. “It’s fairly easy to make good money in an appreciating market, but you’ve got to remember that if we’re not careful, we can give it all back on the other side as it goes down,” he says. Coppess wonders if his company should be buying ammonia at $1,200 per ton now for the spring of 2009. “Is there any dynamic that could come to play and all of a sudden those prices start tumbling after we take our position?” he questions.

Be encouraged. Such risk management is complex and difficult, even for the experts, Stegmann believes. “We’re good businessmen, but we’ve got a company to run, and we don’t have economists on staff to give us inside advice. We’ve found ourselves, particularly in the last year or two, spending so much time trying to understand the market that it’s left us less time to run our business.”

No matter the market situation, dealers we talked to were adamant that the days of business as usual are over. Wilbur-Ellis’ DeYoung says, “The challenge will be not to do what we have always done, but to take production up several levels.”

Swinney agrees: “We’re going to have to be willing to change,” he says. “What we did five years ago is simply history,” and can’t be relied on.

“But I think it’s also the most exciting time we’ve seen in agriculture,” says Stegmann. “The best operators are going to emerge from this period of time stronger and healthier and better than ever with more opportunities than they can imagine.”

Leave a Reply

Fertilizer Stories
FertilizerFall Fertility 2014: Forecasting Fertilizer Use
September 7, 2014
Great crops this year have tapped the soil, and fall work is definitely called for, but how challenging will that get? Read More
Aerial view of the West Fertilizer explosion site
FertilizerFertilizer Companies Blame City For West, TX, Explosion
August 6, 2014
El Dorado Chemical Co. and CF Industries contend the city failed to properly train the first responders and had insufficient protocols in place to battle the April 17, 2013, blaze at West Fertilizer Co. that triggered the explosion. Read More
FertilizerThe Fertilizer Institute: New President, Renewed Energy
February 3, 2014
Chris Jahn relishes the opportunity to lead the organization through the challenging times ahead. Read More
FertilizerA New Cycle For Fertilizer Demand
January 2, 2014
Changes in the corn market could have a major impact on the crop nutrients sector in 2014, say experts. Read More
Top 100 Articles
Milan Kucerak, president/CEO, West Central
CropLife 100West Central Cooperative And Its New President Are A Match Made In Deviation
June 29, 2015
To appreciate just how unique West Central Cooperative is in the world of ag retail, an observer need only consider Read More
Winter Wheat
CropLife 100South Dakota Co-op Member Owners Vote No On Unification
June 26, 2015
The Boards of Directors for North Central Farmers Elevator (NCFE) and Wheat Growers (WG) have announced that member-owners have voted Read More
CropLife 100The Andersons Acquires South Dakota Plant Nutrient Manufacturer Kay-Flo
May 20, 2015
The Andersons, Inc., ranked No. 22 on the CropLife 100, has purchased Kay Flo Industries of North Sioux City, SD. “This Read More
CropLife 100AgGateway’s Barcoding Initiative Progressing Nicely
May 8, 2015
According to legend (or Wikipedia), the first step towards modern bar codes came back in 1948, when Bernard Silver, a Read More
CropLife 100Pinnacle Agriculture Acquires Minnesota Retailer
April 14, 2015
Pinnacle Agriculture Holdings, LLC, ranked No. 6 on the CropLife 100,  has successfully acquired Liebl Ag, LLC in Ada, MN.  Read More
CropLife 100CHS, Aurora Cooperative Complete Fertilizer Storage, Grain Shuttle Loading Facility
April 13, 2015
CHS Inc., the nation’s leading cooperative and ranked No. 5 on the CropLife 100, and Aurora Cooperative (ranked No. 21) Read More
Latest News
Agworld Apple Watch Farm Management
EquipmentAussie Data Management Software Company Making Its Mark…
July 4, 2015
Zach Sheely, vice president of sales and operations, says that several large, well-known U.S. cooperatives (Stanislaus Farm Supply, Wilco-Winfield and Read More
Topcon AGI-4 on MF Planter
EquipmentAutosteer: Compatibility, Accuracy Remain Top Of Mind
July 3, 2015
The world of automatic steering solutions in agriculture has evolved rapidly in the last few years. From after-market add-ons that Read More
ManagementUnited Suppliers/Land ‘O Lakes Merger & Crop Update
July 2, 2015
CropLife’s Paul Schrimpf and Eric Sfiligoj talk about the reasons behind the United Suppliers/Land ‘O Lakes merger and USDA’s recent Read More
Industry NewsBioSafe Adds To Sales Force
July 2, 2015
BioSafe Systems has announced the hire of two new members for its service team. David Britt recently joined the team Read More
Chesapeake Bay
ManagementChesapeake Bay Clean-Up Gets Renewed Attention
July 2, 2015
The Chesapeake Bay has been called one of the most biologically productive ecosystems in the world. It’s also one of Read More
Measuring Bulk Tanks
ManagementBulk Pesticide Compliance: Top 10 Areas Of Improvement …
July 1, 2015
  In honor of the 33-year run of David Letterman’s Late Show, the American Agronomic Stewardship Alliance (AASA) is happy Read More
Industry NewsArysta North America Hires Midwest Sales Manager
July 1, 2015
Arysta LifeScience North America recently announced the hiring of Brian Battles as the Senior Technical Sales Manager for the Midwest Read More
Farmer on tablet
Eric SfiligojThe Never-Ending Battle Against Modern Agriculture
July 1, 2015
In the world of comic books, the character of Superman often refers to the fight to save the world as Read More
Retail FacilitiesBuilding Up Ag Retail
July 1, 2015
In the oftentimes unpredictable world we live in, it’s nice to know some things can be reliably countered on to Read More
Retail FacilitiesMaple River Grain And Agronomy Phases In Site Developme…
July 1, 2015
Marcus Construction helped Maple River Grain and Agronomy in Casselton, ND, with the design-build of its dry fertilizer, liquid chemical/seed Read More
Retail FacilitiesA&B Welding Builds A New Liquid Terminal Hub For Br…
July 1, 2015
To build its new hub facility, Briggs Crop Nutrients enlisted the help of A&B Welding. The result, an efficient facility Read More
Edon Farmers Co-op
Retail FacilitiesNew Marcus Facility At Edon Farmers Co-op Provides More…
July 1, 2015
Edon Farmers Co-Op in Edon, OH, needed a new facility to consolidate outdated locations. Marcus Construction was able to design Read More
Retail FacilitiesKinder Morgan Expands Its Storage With A New Dome Barre…
July 1, 2015
Kinder Morgan wanted additional covered storage at its Dakota Bulk Terminal on the Mississippi River in St. Paul, MN. With Read More
Retail FacilitiesHeartland Tank Protects Fertilizer From Extreme Cold At…
July 1, 2015
The Arthur Companies in Harvey, ND, enlisted the help of Heartland Tank Companies to develop a new liquid fertilizer facility Read More
The McGregor Co. fertilizer loadout
Retail FacilitiesThe McGregor Co. Partners With Kahler Automation To Cre…
June 30, 2015
Kahler Automation helped The McGregor Co. expand its Clarkston, WA, operation with unstaffed loadout technology that enables customers to pick Read More
Dry and Liquid Plant
Retail FacilitiesKahler Automation Helps CHS Dakota Ag Cooperative Build…
June 30, 2015
CHS Dakota Ag Cooperative in Mooreton, ND, wanted a liquid/dry blender system that could meet the needs of its customers Read More
Crop InputsLand O’Lakes, United Suppliers To Merge Crop Inpu…
June 29, 2015
Land O’Lakes, Inc. and United Suppliers, Inc. of Ames, IA, today announced their intent to merge their crop inputs businesses. Read More
FungicidesHelena To Distribute Unique Summit Agro Fungicide
June 29, 2015
RANMAN 400 SC fungicide, the only fungicide with a FRAC group 21 designation, is now part of the innovative Summit Read More