Applications May Require Waste Permits

A new decision by the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals could require custom applicators and growers who apply their own crop protection products to obtain a permit when applying on or near water. CropLife America, the Agricultural Retailers Association, and other industry groups have expressed concern that the Clean Water Act ruling may set an unfavorable precedent for the ag community.

On Jan. 7, a panel of judges with the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals found EPA was incorrect in saying all pesticide applications were exempt from rules for discharging "pollutants" and therefore would not need permits under the agency’s National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES). The court also rejected EPA’s argument that pesticide is discharged from a point source, but the residue does not exist until after the discharge is complete, so it should be treated as a nonpoint source pollutant.

The decision means that commercial pesticide applications to, over, and around waterways will now require NPDES permits, which mainly affects areas which grow rice or require mosquito control.

By vacating that EPA final rule, the court in essence sent EPA regulators back to the drawing board to reconsider Clean Water Act regulations. The Clean Water Act prohibits any pollutant from being discharged into navigable waters from a point source without an EPA permit.

Several agricultural groups, including CropLife America and the National Cotton Council of America, have petitioned the court to support that pesticide applications did not qualify as pollutant discharges. The petitioners have 45 days to file an appeal with the full Sixth Circuit court.

"We maintain that pesticides should not be classified as pollutants under the CWA, as they serve an intended beneficial purpose and are well regulated already by EPA’s Office of Pesticides," said Jay Vroom, CLA president and CEO. "Though we’re disappointed by other parts of the court’s conclusion, we are pleased that the panel acknowledged that EPA was correct in its determination that not all pesticides should be considered pollutants."

"There are legal questions raised by this decision which are left unanswered," Doug Nelson, CLA executive vice president and general counsel, said in a statement. While the court vacated the current final rules, it did not give the EPA direction on how new final rules should be written. "As a result, this ruling may require further review by this court en banc, a subsequent court decision or a legislative solution to insure American agriculture is not jeopardized."

Obtaining a standard NPDES permit is a lengthy task. Most states require a series of forms, including estimations of the amount of pollutants to be discharged, maps showing pollutant flow to streams, where those streams go, and which water users might be affected, and an annual fee of several hundred dollars. State permitting agencies have 180 days to review each permit application, and if accepted, have another 45-day public comment period before issuing the permit. Several states, however, have set precedent for simplifying the NPDES permit process by granting "general permits," which allows anyone meeting a set of criteria to apply under an already approved permit.

According to court documents, Washington State and California have a general permit process that applies to pesticide applicators.

(Sources: Agricultural Retailers Association, CropLife America, and KFGO.com)

Leave a Reply

Latest News
ManagementReviewing MAGIE 2015
September 2, 2015
CropLife Editor Eric Sfiligoj talks what he saw at the recent Midwest AG Industries Exposition (MAGIE) show. Read More
Melissa Olds Dow AgroSciences
Crop InputsDow AgroSciences: Highlighting The Past, Present & …
September 2, 2015
In general, media events held by large agricultural suppliers tend to focus primarily on what plans the company has in Read More
Mobile tablet
OpinionTaking Data Head On
September 2, 2015
As you read this column, I’m hoping that if you picked up the phone and gave me a call, you’d Read More
Young soybean field
Industry NewsArysta LifeScience Announces New Business Unit Head For…
September 1, 2015
Arysta LifeScience North America announces the addition of Rico Christensen, Business Unit Head, North America. Christensen will have responsibility for Read More
Wilbur Ellis Pink Soybean Seed Treatment
Crop InputsWilbur-Ellis Goes Pink With Soybean Seed Treatments For…
September 1, 2015
This past year, proceeds of pink-dyed soybeans treated and sold to Wilbur-Ellis seed customers in Chester, SD, went to two Read More
SprayersNORAC Active Wing Roll Slated For More Sprayers
September 1, 2015
NORAC Systems, a member of the Topcon Positioning Group, announces the release of Active Wing Roll for RoGator, Apache, New Read More
Syngenta Sign
FungicidesSyngenta’s Newest Fungicide Receives EPA Approval
September 1, 2015
Syngenta announced today that its newest succinate dehydrogenase inhibitor (SDHI) fungicide – Solatenol – has received registration from EPA and Read More
Flooded corn in Indiana
Crop InputsDelaying The Fertilizer Decision
September 1, 2015
Comments gathered from several retailers recently evidenced a classic good-news-bad-news scenario. Good news is prices and supplies of nitrogen, phosphate, Read More
StewardshipBee Buffer Strip Initiative Seeks 100 Ohio Farmers
August 31, 2015
The U.S. Bee Buffer Project, an initiative of the Pollinator Partnership (P2), Burt’s Bees and The Burt’s Bees Greater Good Read More
2015 ShowStopper Award, MAGIE
EquipmentA ShowStopper From Case IH: The Patriot 2250
August 31, 2015
For nine years now, visitors to the yearly Midwest AG Industries Exposition (MAGIE) show have been tasked with not only Read More
Crop InputsMonsanto, FMC Expand Roundup Ready PLUS Platform
August 31, 2015
FMC Corp. and Monsanto Co. announced today an expanded agreement to continue their participation in the Roundup Ready PLUS Crop Read More
Deere Nutrient Applicator
Eric SfiligojThe Good & Bad News From MAGIE
August 31, 2015
As I write this column, I’ve just returned from the annual Midwest AG Industries (MAGIE) trade show in Bloomington, IL. Read More
CPS Morenci receiving its 4R certification
StewardshipCPS Morenci Becomes First Michigan Facility Certified I…
August 31, 2015
The 4R Nutrient Stewardship Certification Program has announced that Crop Production Services, Inc.’s facility located in Morenci, MI, has been Read More
EquipmentDeere Announces Soucy Track Distribution Alliance
August 28, 2015
John Deere announces an alliance with Soucy Track to sell and distribute products through the John Deere dealer channel. “This Read More
FertilizerFall-Applied Phosphorus: A Rooted Investment
August 28, 2015
As commodity prices decrease and input prices continue to rise, farmers are seeking more efficient strategies for meeting a high Read More
Monsanto Sign
Crop InputsWhat’s Next For Monsanto, Syngenta?
August 28, 2015
After dropping its $47 billion bid to take over Swiss agribusiness firm Syngenta, Monsanto may be turning its focus to Read More
Golden Harvest Corn stalks
Crop InputsMonsanto: Syngenta Not The Only Horse In Crop Protectio…
August 28, 2015
Monsanto Co, having ditched an audacious $46 billion (£30 billion) offer for Syngenta AG, may downshift to a humbler strategy Read More
ManagementConsolidation hits and a miss; And a look at China’s ch…
August 28, 2015
As Monsanto suspends its pursuit of Syngenta, consolidation news at the retail and distribution level heats up. CropLife magazine’s Executive Read More