The Lingering Aftershocks From West Fertilizer

Everyone’s Problem

Not surprisingly, reaction to the West Fertilizer disaster was swift. The popular press blamed the owner for “trying to hide something” by not filing reports with the proper agencies and being allowed to operate “so close to populated areas.” Others pointed out that the plant carried only $1 million in liability insurance —  insufficient to cover all the damages inflicted upon the surrounding area (although Texas state law allows fertilizer storage facilities to operate without any liability insurance, even when they store hazardous materials).

In Summers’ view, many of these criticisms are unfair. “Some people have made Donald Adair to be a bad guy or industry outlier — someone who purposely stayed off the grid,” he says. “I don’t believe that’s true. You are not dealing with a tin shed type of person here, trying to stay out of sight. West Fertilizer was an active member of the Texas Ag Industries Association, the state trade association for ag retailers.”

From within the ag retail industry, the debate centered more upon AN as opposed to West Fertilizer’s owner. “Is ammonium nitrate’s time as a major nitrogen source over?” asked Mike Wilson, product manager at Wabash Valley Service Co., Browns, IL, just after the disaster occurred. “That will be decided over the next several months. Do we absolutely have to use it to meet our customer’s needs? Absolutely not. Wabash Valley made the decision five years ago not to handle this product in any quantity. Our customers have adjusted and our doors are still open.”

However, other retailers were just as adamant that AN still holds an important place in agriculture. “There is no good substitute for ammonium nitrate, particularly for pastures and hay fields,” says Mark Egan, agronomist for Black Prairie Agriculture, Shiner, TX. “West is in the middle of the blacklands. Once cotton country, it is now mostly grass with some corn, milo and cotton. It is and has always been low input country because the rain pattern is unpredictable. Because its productivity is unpredictable, spending money on nitrogen has to be conservative and opportunistic. Urea is not a great option because of volatilization concerns. Stabilized urea is no bargain. Ammonium sulfate is okay, but that much sulfur is not needed so it becomes an expensive source. Liquid nitrogen is also problematic in these low input systems because its half urea and one has to be equipped to apply it themselves or hope a custom applicator will do it in a timely manner.”

As for The Asmark Institute’s Summers, his view on this topic has changed dramatically since the West Fertilizer accident. “At first, I was with the people who wanted to do away with AN use in agriculture, but I’ve done a complete 180 on this view,” he says. “Because some fertilizer critics won’t give up after that. These same people will then go about trying to get rid of any products that have nitrate in them. So if we as an industry give up the fight for AN, what comes next?”

Phil Gough, senior vice president for El Dorado Chemical Co., Rockwall, TX, agrees. As he points out, calcium ammonium nitrate is considered “a homogeneous fertilizer mixture,” but has still been manipulated in improvised explosive devices used in Afghanistan. “Urea fertilizer can be manipulated with nitric acid into explosive urea nitrate,” says Gough.

Instead, Summers believes the ag retail industry should embrace efforts to police its own facilities with initiatives such as ResponsibleAg, now being introduced jointly by The Fertilizer Institute and the Agricultural Retailers Association. This would involve having independent parties inspecting facilities that store fertilizer, ultimately awarding them a score on their level of preparedness and helping them to fill in any gaps in their emergency plans.

“As I see it, retailers have two options,” he says. “They can be proactive in ensuring their operations are compliant with the existing rules and regulations, some of which date back to the early 1970s, or the industry can sit still and wait for the government agencies to conclude their reviews of what happened in West, TX, and then enact what they believe will prevent another tragedy from occurring. Everyone — including regulators, legislators and industry — agrees there are already enough regulations, so the most obvious positive course is to ensure that everyone that stores or handles products understands the regulations and works to comply with them. If the agencies see industry proactively working to improve the compliance effort, then they will become partners. ResponsibleAg looks to be the initiative that will effectively help industry improve its compliance effort.”

A Ripple Effect

But this might not be enough to keep new regulations that will directly affect the fertilizer industry from coming into play. Last August, President Barack Obama signed an executive order, Improving Chemical Facility Safety and Security — to require regulatory agencies to deliver recommendations for increasing rules governing the storage of chemicals and fertilizer. And according to Summers, even an event such as the 2014 Elk River chemical spill in West Virginia (where crude 4-methylcyclohexanemethanol was accidently released into the water supply of 300,000 residents) could threaten the market.

“Regulators cannot differentiate between a coal mining company and a retailer with a product held in a containment structure, so I believe it is inevitable that agribusiness will be affected by this issue,” he says. “This could include potential new regulations despite existing federal rules for the containment of pesticides and state-specific rules already in place for liquid fertilizer by most states.”

In fact, one such bill has already been proposed by West Virginia Senator Jay Rockefeller. This would change the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compen­sation and Liability Act to cover “pollutants or contaminants” and increase the clean-up liability cap from $2 million to $4 million. Under the proposed bill’s definition, this would include fertilizer and crop protection products.

“The fertilizer industry is under attack to keep the products we currently use,” concludes Summers. “At the end of the day, we’ve got to do a better job with our products, because one plant damaged the reputation of the entire fertilizer industry as a brand across the country.”

Topics:

Leave a Reply

One comment on “The Lingering Aftershocks From West Fertilizer

  1. Thank you for mentioning the green hay. This is the first I have read about it. Anyone who is familiar with growing, harvesting, and storing hay is familiar with the fire danger posed by wet hay. I wonder why the federal investigators never mentioned it. Are they really that stupid?

    It was nice to read about a Homeland Security type admitting that the limit for ammonium nitrate fertilizer is one ton, not the 400 pounds (which has been widely attributed to a person familiar with Homeland Security operations – or just simply asserted without attribution). The next step (which neither your reporter nor nearly every other reporter involved with this story accomplished) is to check on the web for the actual regulation. The one-ton limit only applies if the ammonium nitrate fertilizer is packaged and ready to ship. If it isn’t, there is NO limit. Homeland Security was not advised of the stored ammonium nitrate because Homeland Security did not want to know about it, and wrote regulations to prevent this reporting. In short, West Fertilizer did all the required government reporting. The government simply failed to do its part.

    One item I have not found addressed in any coverage (official or press) of the explosion is the source of the carbon crystals in the fireball: hot black carbon crystals in the exploding fireball made it glow orange and then red, as it cooled. Without the carbon crystals, the fireball would have been a pale blue. What was the source of the carbon in the explosion: what carbonaceous fuel had been mixed with the ammonium nitrate before it exploded? Had someone poured kerosene on the fertilizer in the hope of producing an explosion? Had West Fertilizer blended in some other carbon-containing fuel? Flour perhaps?

    If the official ATF non-criminal-activity explanation (the pure ammonium nitrate melted and then detonated because it was in the liquid state because of a fire started by the electrical system or the golf cart) were correct, the fireball would have been pale blue, not glowing orange and red, and the smoke plume would have been brown, not sooty grey.

    What was the source of the carbon?

    Whom is the ATF trying not to accuse?

Management Stories

ManagementAgriculture 3.5: A Bumpy Road Ahead
May 24, 2016
You may have read my article a few years ago on Agriculture 3.0, which is a term I coined to Read More
Southern States Cooperative
glyphosate
Crop InputsWHO: Glyphosate ‘Unlikely’ To Cause Cancer
May 16, 2016
Via Reuters.com reporter Kate Kelland: The weed-killing pesticide glyphosate, made by Monsanto and widely used in agriculture and by gardeners, Read More
dicamba, Roundup Ready 2 Xtend
Crop InputsASA: No Dicamba On Roundup Ready 2 Xtend In 2016
May 16, 2016
While Roundup Ready 2 Xtend (RR2X) are tolerant to dicamba and glyphosate herbicides, no dicamba herbicides will be approved for Read More
Trending Articles
Eric SfiligojPity The Monsanto Haters
May 23, 2016
An old saying goes thus: “Be careful what you wish for. You just might get it.” Given current events, there Read More
Monsanto Luling Plant
Crop InputsReport: Bayer Eyeing Monsanto For Possible Mega-Merger
May 16, 2016
Bayer AG is exploring a potential bid for U.S. competitor Monsanto Co. in a deal that would create the world’s Read More
Aerial Drone
Precision AgA Deeper Dive Into The Future Of Precision Ag
May 9, 2016
For about two decades now, through the good and the bad times, the ups and the downs inherent in agriculture, Read More
Palmer amaranth in soybean stubble
HerbicidesWSSA: Billions In Potential Economic Losses From Uncontrolled Weeds
May 4, 2016
What losses would corn and soybean growers experience if they were forced to eliminate herbicides and other control techniques from Read More
Eric SfiligojReasons For Hope In Commodity Prices
May 2, 2016
For many months now, the doomsayers have ruled the day in agriculture. Too much supply with too little demand would Read More
Eric SfiligojMissing The Family Ties In Agriculture
April 25, 2016
By its nature, the agriculture market is cyclical. Up and down cycles come and go with a regular pattern. For Read More
Latest News
ManagementAgriculture 3.5: A Bumpy Road Ahead
May 24, 2016
You may have read my article a few years ago on Agriculture 3.0, which is a term I coined to Read More
Topcon’s X30 display with CropSpec sensors
EquipmentGPS Autosteer Systems: Product Updates From Precision A…
May 24, 2016
Throughout 2015 GPS Steering solutions continued to evolve from what was once an after-market add on, to today’s cab where Read More
Trimble TMX-2050 In-Cab Display
Eric SfiligojThe Precision Ag Revolution Continues
May 24, 2016
It’s funny how much “the first time” tends to mean to someone as they get older. I sometimes can’t recall Read More
Eric Wintemute, AMVAC
Precision AgAMVAC Ups The Ante With New Precision Ag Technology
May 24, 2016
A potentially industry-changing at-plant soil treatment system from American Vanguard Corp., or AMVAC, is coming soon to large growers in Read More
Dry and Liquid Plant
CropLife 100CropLife 100 Map
May 24, 2016
The new CropLife 100 map shows the locations of each of the headquarters of the 2015 CropLife 100 retailers. The interactive Read More
Southern States Cooperative
Corn Field
Industry NewsTiger-Sul Names Veteran Account Manager To Lead Central…
May 23, 2016
With the continuing growth of the sulphur bentonite and precision crop nutrient industry, global agriculture firm H.J. Baker has announced that Read More
Bayer sign
Industry NewsReuters: Bayer Defies Critics With $62 Billion Monsanto…
May 23, 2016
German drugs and crop chemicals group Bayer has offered to buy U.S. seeds company Monsanto for $62 billion in cash, Read More
Eric SfiligojPity The Monsanto Haters
May 23, 2016
An old saying goes thus: “Be careful what you wish for. You just might get it.” Given current events, there Read More
Industry NewsCompass Minerals Hires Industry Veteran To Lead Plant N…
May 19, 2016
Compass Minerals has hired plant nutrition industry veteran Vatren Jurin to steer the company’s portfolio expansion into specialty liquid micronutrient Read More
ASMARK Retailers LIVE! Tour 2016 Group shot The Andersons
CropLife 100The Andersons Rejects Unsolicited Proposal From HC2
May 19, 2016
The Andersons, Inc. has announced that its Board of Directors has rejected two non-binding, highly conditional, unsolicited proposals from HC2 Read More
glyphosate
Crop InputsWHO: Glyphosate ‘Unlikely’ To Cause Cancer
May 16, 2016
Via Reuters.com reporter Kate Kelland: The weed-killing pesticide glyphosate, made by Monsanto and widely used in agriculture and by gardeners, Read More
dicamba, Roundup Ready 2 Xtend
Crop InputsASA: No Dicamba On Roundup Ready 2 Xtend In 2016
May 16, 2016
While Roundup Ready 2 Xtend (RR2X) are tolerant to dicamba and glyphosate herbicides, no dicamba herbicides will be approved for Read More
CPP, glyphosate, dicamba, atrazine,
Crop InputsReport: Congress Pressing EPA On Glyphosate Review Hand…
May 16, 2016
Via Reuters.com reporter P.J. Huffstutter: U.S. lawmakers have asked EPA to explain why it published – and then withdrew – Read More
Monsanto Luling Plant
Crop InputsReport: Bayer Eyeing Monsanto For Possible Mega-Merger
May 16, 2016
Bayer AG is exploring a potential bid for U.S. competitor Monsanto Co. in a deal that would create the world’s Read More
ManagementAsmark Institute Tour Observations
May 12, 2016
Special Guest CropLife Field Editor Matthew Grassi discusses his week-long visit with 45 ag retailers as part of the Asmark Read More
MicronutrientsCompass Minerals Expands Trial Work For Wolf Trax Innov…
May 12, 2016
Fertilizer manufacturer Compass Minerals continues to expand the evaluation program for its Wolf Trax micronutrient fertilizer products, according to a Read More
Young Corn Closeup
Industry NewsArysta Adds To Marketing Team
May 12, 2016
Arysta LifeScience North America recently announced the addition of David Davies to its marketing team. As marketing manager, Davies will Read More