Seed Money

In my September column, I discussed data from AgKnowlogy’s Customer Ex­perience Monitor showing full-service retailers often have a lower Net Promoter Score (NPS) for seed vs. farmer-dealer seed specialists. While a full-service retailer might have a NPS in the 25% to 35% range, a Pioneer or DeKalb seed specialist could often have an NPS in the range 55% to 70%.

Retailers ask us what is a good NPS. Each industry is different based on customer expectations and the performance of companies in the sector. For companies in the banking and cell phone businesses, low scores are common. To date, we are not seeing the high scores in ag retailing that retailers assume. There is much work to be done. This column discusses some of the financial impact of Passives and Detractors on your seed business.

Setting The Table

In our work with retailers to uncover their local drivers of loyalty, the concept of “consideration set” is useful. Imagine its time to replace your family car. What manufacturer is your first choice and who else would you consider? Is there a maker you would not consider based on your past experience or comments you have heard from friends? Growers also have a first and second choice of retailer for their crop inputs. Whether you are in the Primary or Secondary position in their Consideration Set has serious consequences related to loyalty and profitability.

The graph compares the total share of business a retailer has received from customers with his Net Promoter Score by category. The highest share of business is in fertilizer (86%) from customers who consider the retailer to be their Primary supplier for this category. Notice the total share of business drops to 49% in fertilizer for customers who consider the retailer to be their Secondary supplier.

In every category, the retailer receives less share of business from growers who don’t consider him to be their Primary retailer. Some readers believe the sales split in a category between Primary customers and Secondary customers is driven by distance from the plant or other easily understandable factors. While these play a part, we believe share of business (for example, the split between Primary and Secondary) is mostly driven by the experiences customers have with you and conversations with other growers.

The retailer’s Net Promoter Score is highest for fertilizer at 29%. The share of business in each category clearly follows the Net Promoter Score. Looking at seed, we see the retailer’s share of business is only 41% among customers who consider him to be their Primary seed supplier, and only 23% among customers who consider him to be their Secondary supplier. This low share of business is a result of the retailer’s low NPS of 15% for seed. A Net Promoter Score is calculated by taking the percent of Promoters for a business minus the percent of De­trac­tors. Customers and prospects in the Passive segment are not included in the calculation of an NPS. In our example, an NPS of 15% means there are not that many more Promoters vs. Detractors. To demonstrate how large the financial impact is from Passives and Detractors, I will use our findings in seed from the same retailer.

I have shown how the spending lag caused by reduced share of business in the seed category is leaving significant revenue on the table for the retailer in question. The retailer’s Net Promoter Score in seed is 15% (percent of Promoters minus Detractors). The average acres for each customer segment is shown, which allows us to estimate the total acres for each customer segment. Passives on average spend $16 less per acre on seed with the retailer as a consequence of their reduced share of business.

Detractors on average spend $21 less per acre on seed with the retailer. The estimated impact for Passives and Detractors is calculated by multiplying the spending lag times the acres from these customers. The total estimated impact in seed alone from Passives and Detractors is approximately $1.5 million from the 177 customers we studied.

A Big Impact

Across all the retailer’s customers, this financial impact would be much larger. Clearly, this potential upside won’t be captured in one year. Perhaps a reasonable target would be 50% of the upside over two years. Remember — this will drop directly to your bottom line because this increase in share of business is with current customers.

I am attempting to give you a sense of real-life impact and urgency for measuring customer experiences and quantifying their impact. Full-service retailers are struggling to grow their business against local farmer-dealer seed specialists. Based on our work using the Customer Experience Monitor, it appears the local seed specialist offers his customers a superior experience vs. the full-service retailer. Compared to a farmer-seed specialist, a full-service retailer appears to have more Passives and Detractors among his customers.

I say this because so far, full-service retailers have lower Net Promoter Scores for seed than their seed specialist competitors. To break through this glass ceiling, full-service retailers will have to pay more attention to what seed experiences drive loyalty and share of business. They then must put this learning into their strategic planning and assign a manager to be accountable for it. Finally, the resulting refinements to service delivery must be monitored on an ongoing basis if there is to be any hope for the improvement required to catch competitors.

Leave a Reply

Management Stories

StewardshipOhio Water Quality Project To Determine How Much Phosphorus Is Leaving Fields
July 27, 2015
Researchers with the College of Food, Agricultural, and Environmental Sciences at The Ohio State University are looking for farmers in Read More
ManagementFCI Trade Summit Update & Precision Tank Turns 50
July 23, 2015
Editors Dave Frabotta and Eric Sfiligoj discuss the upcoming FCI Trade Summit in Las Vegas, NV, and how Precision Tank Read More
ManagementUpdates On UAV Rules & Crop Conditions
July 16, 2015
CropLife’s Paul Schrimpf and Eric Sfiligoj provide updates on the ongoing UAV regulations debate and how the nation’s crops are Read More
StewardshipOhio Farmers Improving Water Quality Through Fertilizer Applicator Training
July 15, 2015
Since last fall, 6,586 growers and producers responsible for farming some 1 million acres of Buckeye State farmland have gone Read More
Top 100 Articles
CropLife 100Pinnacle Purchases California-Based Specialty Crops Retailer
July 20, 2015
Pinnacle Agriculture Holdings has successfully acquired California-based NH3 Service Co.  Operating as part of Pinnacle’s Performance Agriculture brand, the new locations Read More
Asmus Farm Supply liquid fertilizer facility features 20,000 square feet
CropLife 100Slideshow: Asmus Farm Supply Shows Off Its New Liquid Fertilizer Facility
July 15, 2015
Asmus Farm Supply, Rake, IA, recently added a new liquid fertilizer facility to its company operations. The new liquid fertilizer Read More
CropLife 100Wilbur-Ellis Feed Division Facilities Receive Safe Feed/Safe Food Certification
July 13, 2015
Wilbur-Ellis Co.’s Feed Division, a marketer and distributor of value-added feed ingredients for the aquaculture, livestock and pet food industries Read More
CropLife 100BRANDT Expands To Brazil With Acquisition
July 8, 2015
BRANDT has acquired a majority interest in Target Brasil Fertilizantes Ltda. through its Brazilian subsidiary. Target Brasil manufactures, distributes and Read More
Milan Kucerak, president/CEO, West Central
CropLife 100West Central Cooperative And Its New President Are A Match Made In Deviation
June 29, 2015
To appreciate just how unique West Central Cooperative is in the world of ag retail, an observer need only consider Read More
Winter Wheat
CropLife 100South Dakota Co-op Member Owners Vote No On Unification
June 26, 2015
The Boards of Directors for North Central Farmers Elevator (NCFE) and Wheat Growers (WG) have announced that member-owners have voted Read More
Latest News
StewardshipOhio Water Quality Project To Determine How Much Phosph…
July 27, 2015
Researchers with the College of Food, Agricultural, and Environmental Sciences at The Ohio State University are looking for farmers in Read More
FertilizerKoch Agronomic Services Launches N-TEGRATION Technology
July 27, 2015
Koch Agronomic Services, LLC (KAS) has launched  N-TEGRATION Technology, a process technology platform designed to enable production of enhanced efficiency fertilizers at Read More
HerbicidesExpert: IARC Herbicide Classifications Leading To Confu…
July 24, 2015
Few people in the crop protection industry had heard of the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) before this Read More
ManagementFCI Trade Summit Update & Precision Tank Turns 50
July 23, 2015
Editors Dave Frabotta and Eric Sfiligoj discuss the upcoming FCI Trade Summit in Las Vegas, NV, and how Precision Tank Read More
Palmer pigweed seedhead in cotton
HerbicidesUSDA Deregulates Dow AgroSciences’ Enlist Cotton Trait
July 23, 2015
The USDA today issued its decision deregulating Dow AgroSciences’ Enlist cotton trait in the U.S. The USDA has now completed its Read More
Industry NewsVerdesian Life Sciences Showcases Versatile Product Por…
July 23, 2015
Technology has revolutionized agriculture by bringing farmers, retailers and distributors to the forefront of the digital age. To meet the Read More
FertilizerWSJ: Cf Industries Exploring Merger With Dutch Chemical…
July 23, 2015
U.S. fertilizer maker CF Industries is in advanced merger talks with Amsterdam-listed chemical company OCI NV, the Wall Street Journal Read More
HerbicidesNufarm Releases New Panther SC Herbicide
July 23, 2015
Nufarm has announced the availability of new Panther SC herbicide. Panther SC is the first liquid formulation of flumioxazin available Read More
EquipmentFarmLink Launches Farm Equipment Sharing Program
July 23, 2015
FarmLink has introduced a new online farm equipment sharing community – MachineryLink Sharing – leveraging this new economy business model Read More
HerbicidesCould The South’s Most Troublesome Weed Represent A Thr…
July 22, 2015
Palmer amaranth is undoubtedly the most troublesome weed in the southern United States, taking a devastating toll on both cotton Read More
Industry NewsH.J. Baker Hires New Director Of International Sales
July 22, 2015
Global Agriculture firm H.J. Baker announced today that Steve Langley has joined the company’s Crop Performance Division and Animal Health Read More
InsecticidesSyngenta Recommends Soybean Scouting To Prevent Economi…
July 22, 2015
Proper soybean insect pest control begins with scouting. As the warm weather continues, Syngenta encourages growers to implement a scouting Read More
Crop InputsH.J. Baker Launches Fall Sulphur Campaign
July 22, 2015
H.J. Baker has launched their “Keep Your Future Green – Use Tiger This Fall and Win Big” campaign. The campaign Read More
Central Valley Ag Randolph, NE
Retail FacilitiesStueve Construction Builds Fifth Facility For Central V…
July 21, 2015
Central Valley Ag partnered with Stueve Construction Co. to successfully design and build its Monroe, Oakland, Wakefield and Royal hub facilities Read More
FertilizerNew Research Could Lead To Less Reliance On Nitrogen, E…
July 21, 2015
Farmers often are required to apply nitrogen fertilizers to their crops to maintain quality and improve yields. Worldwide, farmers used Read More
Seed/BiotechMonsanto Targets Farmers, AFBF In Syngenta Takeover
July 21, 2015
As Monsanto Co. struggles to convince rival Syngenta AG to discuss a potential merger, the seed and agrochemical giant is Read More
CHS Building exterior
Retail FacilitiesSackett Helps CHS Expand Blending Facility, Improve Acc…
July 21, 2015
CHS needed a blend plant that could vastly expand their capabilities in St. Charles, MN. The A.J. Sackett & Sons Read More
Industry NewsH.J. Baker Adds To HR Team
July 21, 2015
H.J. Baker announced today that Barbara Sullivan has joined the company’s executive team as Vice President of Human Resources. Prior Read More