Fall Fertilizer Outlook: A Heated Debate

Now that the calendar has turned to September, many ag retailers are gearing up for the usually busy fall fertilizer application season. However, because of the extended drought that gripped much of the Midwest during the summer, there are a fair number of applicators that fear the 2012 fall season will be a non-starter for them.

To appreciate just how deeply this sense of apprehension about 2012 is running, consider this tale from Tim McArdle, COO/vice president for Brandt Consolidated Inc., Springfield, IL. This past July, McArdle was in attendance at the Southwestern Fertilizer Conference, an annual gathering of top fertilizer suppliers and distributors. Normally, this event is dominated by discussion of fertilizer market trends and the finalizing of distribution deals.

This year, however, most of the talk concerned the weather.

“I’m sitting in the San Antonio airport to return from the meeting,” wrote McArdle in a mid-July email. “The drought and its impact was the major discussion point here.”

But will the prospects for 2012 be that bad? Before attempting to answer this question, a brief review of how events have played out during 2012 is in order.

At the beginning of the year, grower-customers were still feeling pretty good. According to USDA, corn acreage was expected to top 96.4 million acres — the largest seeded area figure the U.S. had seen in 75 years. Projections for broad fertilizer usage was also high. An early, dry spring helped growers get virtually all of their seed planted by the end of May, furthering rising hopes for a good 2012 corn season.

How Dry We Are

Unfortunately, the dry spring never really came to an end. Then, a series of slow moving or stationary high pressure systems kept much of the nation’s midsection baking throughout the key corn growing months of June and July. By early August, USDA had designated 1,585 counties in 32 states as disaster areas because of the lack of rainfall. Particularly hard hit were key corn producing states such as Illinois, Iowa and Indiana. But nationwide, USDA rated approximately half of the corn crop as very poor to poor.

From the field, the news supported this analysis. “The crops in Central Illinois are hurt badly,” says McArdle. “The average yield will, at best, be one-half, with many fields in the 0- to 50-bushel range.”

As a result of this, USDA has slashed its harvest projections for corn to 86.4 million acres with yields off 23% from 2011 to 128 bushels per acre.

Still, there are some areas where the drought’s impact appears to be less severe. For example, Ohio corn growers have fared much better than their counterparts in neighboring states. “The full impact [of the drought] is very difficult to predict as some parts of our trade area have experienced severe crop loss while others have had much less,” says Doug Busdeker, senior manager, Northern farm centers for The Andersons Inc., Maumee, OH.

But even with significant crop losses caused of the drought, adds Busdeker, many grower-customers should be protected from complete financial disaster because of their crop insurance policies. However, as Brandt’s McArdle points out, fall cash flow for some growers could be an issue “since crop insurance payments will not come until later.”

The Fall Outlook

So how will this chain of extraordinary events impact the outlook for fall fertilizer? “Well, I think that’s the big question,” says Bill Coen, vice president, plant foods/transportation for MFA Inc., Columbia, MO. “I think everybody’s wondering how the drought will affect fertilization and purchasing habits going into the fall.”

And? “We don’t know the answer to that just yet,” says Coen. “Our guess is, from some of the conversations we’ve had with some of our customers that they’ll kind of wait and see what crops they have, process their insurance claims and then kind of make a decision on what they will do for fertility.”

However, other ag retailers are a bit more pessimistic about the outlook for fall 2012, especially for crop nutrients such as potash (with corn accounting for approximately 45% of annual U.S. usage, according to sources). “Our business will see a reduction of fertilizer sales this fall — up to has much as a 50% reduction,” says Brandt’s McArdle. “Nitrogen should be okay, but it still requires rain before it can be applied.”

Still, ag retailers aren’t completely trying to get a read on fall 2012 without the ability to rely on some historical assistance. In many quarters, market watchers have compared the Drought of 2012 to the last major drought that gripped U.S. agriculture back in 1988. According to USDA statistics, U.S. corn yields in 1988 were off 30% from the previous year to 84.6 bushels per acre — very similar to the 23% loss projected for the 2012 crop.

Despite this drop, however (or because of it), U.S. corn growers moved forward with their 1989 planting intentions with a sense of normalcy — at least when it came to nitrogen fertilizers. According to USDA statistics, corn growers used just shy of 4.5 million tons of nitrogen products during the drought year of 1988. In 1989, they used more than 4.6 million tons of nitrogen fertilizer, an increase of 2.3%.

Looking ahead to fall 2012 and spring 2013, it makes sense that a similar pattern will emerge for nitrogen-based fertilizers, say market watchers, pointing out that corn’s response to nitrogen is usually less during a drier year. “The bottom line is there will be big corn acres again next year and these guys will not shortchange a crop,” says MFA’s Coen. “They want to maximize their yields, so they won’t cut fertilizer to the point that it’s detrimental.”

However, the historical tale of 1988-89 is a bit less positive for the other two macronutrients, phosphate and potash. Perhaps possessing a mindset to “mine” their soils, U.S. corn growers applied just short of 1.8 million tons of phosphate in 1989, down 3.1% from 1988’s total. Potash application took a similar hit, down from 2.5 million tons in 1988 to 2.2 million tons in 1989.

So if history repeats itself in 2012, nitrogen fertilizer applications should trend slightly higher during this year’s fall season while phosphate and potash application would suffer some setbacks. But some ag retailers don’t think this will happen, especially given that plant roots need to grow where phosphate and potash are located in the soil and 2012’s severely dry summer will have likely moved these nutrients further down into the ground.

“They’re just smarter than that,” says Coen about his grower-customers. “They’re good operators and they watch their fertility, so I’m hopeful that we’ll have some good movement in the fall. I don’t think fertilizer will be cut back as much as people think it will be.”

Part of the reason for this optimism for 2012 could relate back to good-old-fashioned money. Back in 1988, the crop losses translated not only into lower yields but fertilizer prices as well. According to USDA statistics, nitrogen fertilizer prices dropped an average of 6% per ton between October 1988 and October 1989. Likewise, the price for potash per ton fell 2.6% while phosphate prices dipped 9.5%.

At the start of the year, fertilizer market analysts were predicting double-digit price increases for the three macronutrients for the 2012 season, buoyed by robust commodity prices and grower income. Nitrogen fertilizers were expected to be approximately 20% on average, with phosphate and potash both increasing in price by 38% apiece. Chances are, say market insiders, these kinds of across-the-board fertilizer increases might not come to pass.

Barge Trouble

Then again, fertilizer prices could end up higher this fall. However, the culprit won’t be tied to all-time record highs for commodity prices or higher planting intentions for spring 2013. The problem, says Coen, could be transportation.

“I think the bigger issue this fall is going to be our river system and getting products moved where we need them in a timely fashion — especially if this crop is early, which it looks like it will be,” he says. “I think we may see fertilizer movement start a little early, but the river system is such that we’ve got a lot of ports that cannot unload barges right now.”

The facts support this assessment. According to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the Drought of 2012 has reduced water levels on important transport routes such as the Mississippi River that nine barges have run aground since the beginning of July. Every 1-inch loss of water decreases the carrying capacity of a barge by 17 tons of cargo, says the American Waterways Operators.

In essence, this reduces the number of barges that can be moved in tandem on the river by 10 or so, say experts, and the carrying loads from 2,200 tons per barge to 1,600 tons per barge.

“I think we can still get barges up the river, but there are a lot of docks that are too low for barges to be unloaded,” says Coen. He adds that fewer barges carrying smaller loads means suppliers will need to have more shipments made to equal their delivery order totals, which could significantly increase transport costs.

While questions still remain about how fall fertilizer applications will pan out in 2012, ag retailers say their grower-customers remain relatively positive in their outlooks for the future.

“Where the drought was most severe, growers will likely be more cautious, but will still prepare for next year’s crop,” says The Andersons’ Busdeker. “Considering the demand for corn overall, we expect the season to still be reasonably good.”

Brandt’s McArdle agrees. “We corn prices where they are, we are optimistic about 2013,” he says.

Topics:

Leave a Reply

Fertilizer Stories

Corn Field
FertilizerProtect Applied Manure Straight From the Manure Pit to the Field
August 10, 2017
Farmers who use liquid manure to fertilize corn crops can now mix Instinct nitrogen stabilizer in their pit for easy Read More
Corn-Irrigation
Crop InputsNitrogen: Why More Later May Be Better
August 2, 2017
The fact that new corn hybrids require an ever-increasing yield potential, and therefore a growing appetite for nitrogen and other Read More
Darin Lickfeldt Verdesian In Field
Crop InputsVerdesian: Sustainability Goes Hand in Hand with Profits
July 25, 2017
Sustainability is a hot topic in agriculture these days. And while measuring sustainability and its on-farm impact can seem difficult Read More
Soil soybean closeup
FertilizerThe 4Rs and Potassium
July 17, 2017
Are we meeting crop K needs? Using the 4R nutrient stewardship approach of selecting the right source at the right Read More
Trending Articles
Iowa waterways
Stewardship2,600 Iowa Farmers Commit $8.7 Million to Water Quality Practices
August 9, 2017
Iowa Secretary of Agriculture Bill Northey announced Tuesday that a record number of Iowa farmers signed up to install nutrient Read More
Greg Musson, Gar Tootelian
CropLife 100Cause of Gar Tootelian Fire Under Investigation
August 7, 2017
Over one hundred firefighters and equipment responded to a four-alarm shop fire at the Gar Tootelian, Inc. (GAR) facility in Read More
Rob Versprille
ManagementCeres Solutions, North Central Co-op Merger to Bring New Opportunities for Indiana, Michigan Farmers
August 1, 2017
More than 40,000 customers and almost 9,000 Indiana and Michigan farmers will begin doing business with the new Ceres Solutions Read More
CPS-Norwood-and-Dupont-reps
Eric SfiligojA Message to Ag Retailers: Do Tell Your Good Stories
July 26, 2017
As the daughter of a peanut farmer, Krysta Harden, Chief Sustainability Officer for DuPont Crop Protection, understands the importance ag Read More
Tim Hassinger Dow AgroSciences President and CEO
Crop InputsDow’s Tim Hassinger Named President, CEO of Lindsay Corp.
July 24, 2017
Lindsay Corp. has  announced the appointment of Timothy Hassinger as president and CEO and a member of its board of Read More
Stewardship‘Gonna Fly Now’ with Environmental Respect
July 20, 2017
One of the most memorable moments in movie history occurred in the Academy Award-winning 1976 film “Rocky.” Haven gotten his Read More
Latest News
Corn Seed
Seed/BiotechSeed Innovations Benefit All of the Seed Industry
August 17, 2017
Innovations from throughout the seed industry help address many of the economic, environmental and health issues we face as a Read More
SpreadersGVM to Introduce New Prowler at MAGIE
August 17, 2017
The newest Prowler in GVM’s line-up will be introduced next week at the Midwest Ag Industries Expo (MAGIE), August 23 Read More
AcreEdge bag
Seed/BiotechLandus Cooperative’s AcreEdge Seed Brand Gears Up for 2…
August 17, 2017
Growers in more than 26 Iowa and Minnesota counties are seeing field signs with a new brand name at end Read More
Engenia soybeans
ManagementCorn and Soybean Yield Forecasts Larger than Expected
August 17, 2017
The USDA’s August Crop Production report contained larger-than-expected forecasts for the 2017 U.S. corn and soybean crops. At 169.5 bushels Read More
ManagementU.S. Ag Secretary Introduces SCORE
August 17, 2017
U.S. Agriculture Secretary Sonny Perdue signed a new agreement to support new and beginning farmers. On August 5, Perdue joined Read More
CHS-FFA-Minnesota
CropLife 100CHS and FFA: A Homerun Partnership
August 17, 2017
CHS hosted the Minnesota FFA for its annual FFA night at CHS Field. FFA students, educators and CHS leadership enjoyed Read More
Greg Musson, Gar Tootelian
CropLife 100Gar Tootelian Foundation Donates Half Million Dollars t…
August 16, 2017
Students at Immanuel Elementary are looking forward to the first day of school for two reasons this year. One, they Read More
Water Drainage
StewardshipNew System Could Remove Two Water Pollutants from Ag Fi…
August 14, 2017
Algae blooms in the Gulf of Mexico use up the majority of the oxygen in the water, leading to massive Read More
Eric SfiligojThe Top 10 Crop Protection Companies, Post-Mega Mergers
August 14, 2017
Everyone loves a good Top 10 list. In fact, some prominent celebrities such as David Letterman spent much of their Read More
ManagementThe DuPont-Granular Deal, Dicamba Update, and Upcoming …
August 11, 2017
Matthew Grassi joins Paul Schrimpf for the second week in a row to talk about DuPont’s acquisition of Granular, as Read More
Soybeans weeds
HerbicidesOngoing Evaluation Key to Controlling Weeds, Improving …
August 10, 2017
As the sun bears down on record U.S. soybean acres this August, farmers keep their eyes on their fields to Read More
Young Corn Plants
Seed/BiotechMycogen Seeds Offers Novel Product to Battle Pythium, O…
August 10, 2017
After a season plagued by seedling diseases caused by cool, wet soils at planting, farmers have a new option to Read More
Corn Field
FertilizerProtect Applied Manure Straight From the Manure Pit to …
August 10, 2017
Farmers who use liquid manure to fertilize corn crops can now mix Instinct nitrogen stabilizer in their pit for easy Read More
Iowa waterways
Stewardship2,600 Iowa Farmers Commit $8.7 Million to Water Quality…
August 9, 2017
Iowa Secretary of Agriculture Bill Northey announced Tuesday that a record number of Iowa farmers signed up to install nutrient Read More
Natives-First-Purple_Prairie_Clover
Seed/BiotechLa Crosse Seed Continues Focus on Soil and Water Conser…
August 9, 2017
La Crosse Seed is doing its part to lead communication to ag retailers across the country on the importance of Read More
HerbicidesAg Secretary Perdue Comments on Dicamba Issue
August 9, 2017
Agriculture Secretary Sonny Perdue indicated to reporters this week that he would like to see the industry work out a Read More
Treated-Seed-in-planter
Seed/BiotechSeed Treatment Q&A: Insight from Iowa State’s…
August 8, 2017
Technology has changed drastically since the 1990s. Televisions are thinner, phones are smaller and tractors can steer themselves. Technology has Read More
soybeans
Seed/BiotechWhen and Why to Double Inoculate Your Soybeans
August 8, 2017
Double inoculation is the act of using a double application of a rhizobial inoculant. This quickly establishes high populations of Read More